01 May 2025

The Eternaut: Review + Themes

Television keeps turning to stories of collapse. Pandemics, wars, environmental ruin—the world ends over and over, and we can’t seem to get enough.

Into this crowded field steps The Eternaut, Netflix’s stark and atmospheric adaptation of a nearly 70-year-old Argentine comic, originally created by Héctor Germán Oesterheld and Francisco Solano López. What sets it apart isn’t just its South American setting, but its tone—slow, grim, human—and the way it leans into the psychological toll of surviving the unthinkable.

The original comic is a cultural touchstone in Argentina. Locals came in with expectations. For everyone else, the show has to carry its own weight.

It starts with a snowfall. Buenos Aires, not exactly known for its winters, is blanketed in flakes that kill on contact. Within hours, the city is quiet. Bodies in the streets, radios dead, heat cut off. The end comes fast, and it doesn’t explain itself.

We meet Juan Salvo, played by Ricardo Darín, a man in a gas mask trying to find his daughter and ex-wife in a frozen hellscape. The first episode drops us straight into the chaos. One moment, friends are playing cards. The next, death is falling from the sky. That jarring shift—from everyday routine to instant apocalypse—is one of the show’s best moves. It feels real. It stings.

The early part of the series focuses on the survivors holed up in a house, clinging to each other and trying to understand what just happened. There's no exposition dump. Just confusion, grief, and a creeping dread. When they do step outside, the world is unrecognizable. The snow is beautiful. It’s also death.

the eternaut review themes netflix reddit


Like The Walking Dead or Station Eleven, the show mines tension from dwindling resources, conflicting personalities, and the constant threat of violence. But The Eternaut digs deeper into the psychology of disaster. 

How do you trust people when survival might mean keeping to yourself? 

What’s the point of cooperation when everyone could be dead tomorrow? 

These aren’t abstract questions here. They define who lives.

It’s not just the cold or the snow or even the dying that makes this world hard to survive. It’s the breakdown of basic humanity. And yet, the show doesn’t wallow in despair. There’s a throughline of hope—not optimism, but stubbornness. The characters adapt. They get smarter. They learn to fight without becoming monsters.

Juan Salvo is the anchor. At first, he just wants to get his family back. But as the stakes rise, so does he. He becomes the moral center, the one still trying to do the right thing when that seems almost delusional. Darín plays him with quiet desperation—tough, shaken, but never hollowed out.

Around him, we meet others. Alfredo, the loyal best friend. Omar, a potential wildcard. Their arcs echo the broader theme: how crisis exposes and sometimes rewrites who people are. Trust isn’t automatic. It has to be earned, tested, broken, and maybe rebuilt.

The series also captures something distinctly Argentine. It’s not just the setting, though the image of a snow-covered Buenos Aires is unforgettable. It’s the undercurrent—this feeling of isolation, of being left to deal with disaster alone. The show doesn’t push the metaphor too hard, but it lingers: Argentina has a long history of political upheaval and social trauma. That context gives the apocalypse a different weight.

Visually, The Eternaut is stunning. The snow is eerie. The makeshift survival gear feels real, not cosplay. The contrast between the vibrant city and its silent, ruined shell creates a haunting mood. Production design does heavy lifting here—there’s detail, but also restraint. Nothing looks overproduced.

And while comparisons to The Last of Us are inevitable, the two series diverge in tone and tempo. The Eternaut is less polished, more grounded. Its apocalypse is quieter. More banal. No zombies. Just snow and silence. That restraint makes it more unsettling. Where The Last of Us thrives on tension and violence, The Eternaut builds its dread through isolation and slow realization.

It's not flashy. It’s not trying to reinvent the genre. But it is trying to do something specific: show what happens when ordinary people are left in an extraordinary hell, and no one is coming to save them.

And that’s the core of it. The Eternaut isn’t just another entry in the genre. It’s a slow-burn character study wrapped in a science fiction premise. For those tired of the same old post-apocalyptic beats, it offers something quieter, stranger, and more personal.

How Wolverine becomes the 'Old Man Logan' of the X-Men Films Time Line

Wolverine was never just another mutant. 

Born James Howlett in late 19th-century Canada and raised under the alias Logan, he lived through more wars than most people can name. By the time the original X-Men timeline hits its breaking point, Logan has fought in World Wars I and II, teamed up with Captain America in the 1940s (a nod carried over from the comics), and survived the Weapon X program that fused unbreakable adamantium to his skeleton—leaving his memory shattered and his soul hardened.

By the early 2000s, he joins the X-Men under Professor Charles Xavier (Patrick Steward, Picard).  

Initially a reluctant ally, Logan eventually becomes their most loyal protector, forming bonds with Jean Grey, Rogue, and even Cyclops—despite frequent friction over leadership and Jean’s affections. His instinct to protect the vulnerable, especially young mutants, makes him more than a fighter. He becomes the school’s unlikely cornerstone.

But this world doesn't last. In the original timeline, Mystique’s assassination of Bolivar Trask in 1973 escalates anti-mutant hysteria. Her DNA, capable of adaptive transformation, is weaponized to create Sentinels—machines capable of mimicking and countering any mutant ability. Magneto’s extremism doesn’t help; his battles with the X-Men over the decades, from Liberty Island to Alcatraz, only deepen human fear.

By 2023, the world is unrecognizable. The Sentinels have evolved into biomechanical hunters, wiping out entire populations. Iconic X-Men like Storm, Cyclops, Jean Grey, and Nightcrawler are either dead or vanished. Magneto and Xavier, bitter enemies for decades, are now desperate allies. Kitty Pryde, Colossus, Bishop, and others hide in remote ruins, surviving only through short-term time displacement tactics.

And Wolverine? 

He’s still standing. Still fighting. Still healing. His body, like his will, refuses to die. But survival isn’t enough. He’s the only one who can go back and change it.


Changing History in Days of Future Past

The plan is audacious: project someone’s consciousness into their past body to stop the event that triggered the Sentinel program. Only Logan can survive the psychic strain. His healing factor is no longer just a mutation—it’s the thread that ties the X-Men’s past to their possible future.

When he wakes in 1973, Logan finds himself in a broken world all over again. But this time it’s emotional ruin. Xavier is lost. The Vietnam War shattered his school, drove away his students, and pushed him into using a serum that robs him of his powers but lets him walk. This isn’t the Professor X Logan remembers. This is a junkie, a recluse, a man who’s given up.

Wolverine becomes the mentor. The older brother. The conscience. He tells Charles what’s coming—not just the Sentinels, but the death of his dream. He echoes the comic-book Logan who mentored Kitty Pryde and Jubilee. He becomes the gruff protector, urging Charles to be the man he’s supposed to be.

Alongside Beast, Logan helps break Magneto out of his Pentagon prison—a scene that riffs on both the comics' God Loves, Man Kills and Fatal Attractions arcs, where Xavier and Magneto are forced into uneasy alliances. Michael Fassbender’s Magneto here is still young, still radical, and still brilliant. And like his older self, he’s both a necessary ally and an unstable powder keg.

Then comes Raven. Mystique, raised like a sister by Charles, is already on her own path of vengeance. She’s no longer the quiet side character from the first X-Men film—she’s evolved into a mutant revolutionary. And Logan knows her choice will either save or doom the future.

The layers pile up. Logan isn’t just a time traveler. He’s a man confronting his own past, battling trauma, bearing memories no one else has. When he sees William Stryker—his future torturer—he snaps. For a moment, his young self surfaces, confused and wild. That tension between past and future self, between man and weapon, never fully disappears.

Still, the mission holds. Just barely. Raven hesitates. Charles reaches her. History tilts.

The Altered Timeline: Logan as the Continuity Anchor

The next time Logan opens his eyes, everything is different. It’s 2023 again—but it’s not the wasteland he left. 

It’s the dream Xavier once had.

The mansion is alive with students. The Sentinels were never built. Scott Summers is leading. Jean Grey lives. Hank McCoy teaches. Storm, Bobby, Rogue—they’re all here. The team that was torn apart by war and death is now whole again.

Only Logan remembers the cost.

That makes him unique. 

Not just in terms of memory—but cosmically.

 He is the single character who spans both timelines with full awareness. He remembers X-Men, X2, The Last Stand, The Wolverine. He remembers Jean’s death, Charles’s sacrifice, the war, the loss. And he also remembers fixing it. For everyone else, time flows normally. For Logan, it split and reformed—and he holds both versions inside.

In comic lore, the concept of timeline memory is rare but not unheard of. Characters like Cable, Bishop, and Rachel Summers experience fractured realities. Logan now shares that burden. He becomes the audience’s anchor—the only one who remembers the world we watched fall apart, and the one who helped rebuild it.

It’s not just science fiction. It’s personal. His reunion with Xavier confirms that Charles knows. Somehow, he remembers the man who visited him in 1973. He welcomes Logan back—not just to the school, but to a world that doesn’t know how much it owes him.
A Man with Two Histories: Memory, Identity, and Trauma

Logan’s gift is his memory. And his curse is the same.

Even before time travel, Logan’s story was one of fractured identity. 

Amnesia, mind-wipes, Weapon X conditioning—all of it left him chasing his past like a shadow. 

His memory was manipulated by groups like the Weapon Plus program, the CIA, and Stryker’s team. He was used as a killer, discarded, then hunted.

Now he carries an entire erased timeline in his mind. He remembers killing Jean. He remembers fighting beside Xavier in the ruins. He remembers dying. And no one else does. Even Jean, whom he once loved and lost, greets him like nothing ever happened. That disconnect is more isolating than war.

This isn’t just a sci-fi twist. It’s a thematic core.

 In the comics, Wolverine’s arc is often about reconciling past lives—Weapon X, Team X, the X-Men, the Avengers, the samurai in Japan. He’s a man made of contradictions. Soldier and teacher. Weapon and healer. Killer and father.

The films tap into this. When Logan walks the halls of the new Xavier School, he looks like a ghost in a home he barely believes is real. And yet—this is his reward. Not just survival, but proof that his pain had meaning. 

That he endured so others wouldn’t have to.

Logan in 2029: Memory in a Dying World

Then comes Logan—set in 2029. 

A dry, dying America. 

No new mutants. 

No X-Men. 

No hope.

Logan is old. Broken. His healing factor is faltering, poisoned by the adamantium inside him. Charles Xavier, once the world’s greatest mind, now suffers from degenerative brain disease. And Logan is his nurse. His bodyguard. His last friend.

This future doesn’t line up cleanly with Days of Future Past’s happy ending. That’s intentional. Logan isn’t about continuity—it’s about consequence.

Hints tie it to the revised timeline. 

The Westchester Incident. 

The Essex Corporation collecting Logan’s DNA (a callback to X-Men: Apocalypse). 

Charles remembers the Statue of Liberty—possibly referencing the 2000 film. But mostly, Logan feels like the end of all timelines. A convergence of everything he’s been through.

And yet, even here, he remembers. He dreams of Jean. He mutters names in his sleep. He mourns a life few around him ever saw.

Enter Laura—X-23. 

A clone. 

A daughter. 

She is the last echo of the X-Men’s legacy, and the first note of something new. Logan doesn’t want to care. 

But he does. Of course he does.

In saving her, in dying for her, he finds peace. His final words—“So this is what it feels like”—are more than just a nod to death. They’re a release. After lifetimes of pain, of remembering what no one else could, Logan gets to stop running.

-

Across wars, timelines, and realities, Wolverine stands as the lone constant. A memory-keeper. A walking contradiction. A man who outlived gods, enemies, and friends.

He is the thread that binds the original trilogy, the First Class prequels, and the futures yet to come. He’s the character who remembers everything—who paid the price for everyone else’s second chance.

And that’s what makes his arc more than tragic. It makes it mythic.

Wolverine didn’t just survive time. He gave it meaning.

How X-Men: Days of Future Past Rewrote the X-Men Movie Timeline

X-Men: Days of Future Past didn’t just tell a story.

It hit the reset button.

By the time the credits rolled, the movie had rearranged nearly every major event in the X-Men film universe. And it did it with one bold move: time travel.

Let’s back up.

The X-Men movies had been building a timeline since 2000’s X-Men, but things got messy.

Continuity was inconsistent, characters aged oddly, and events from X-Men: First Class (set in 1962) didn’t always line up with what we saw later.

Enter Days of Future Past, a film that uses the apocalyptic future of the Sentinels as an excuse to send Wolverine back to 1973 to alter history.

The mission?

Stop Mystique from assassinating Bolivar Trask, an act that triggers the creation of the mutant-hunting Sentinels and decades of war.

January Jones / Emma Frost X-Men: First Class (2011)
January Jones as Emma Frost in X-Men: First Class (2011)

Here’s the key twist: by preventing that assassination and changing the course of events in the ‘70s, Days of Future Past wipes out everything from the original timeline—including X-Men, X2, The Last Stand, and even The Wolverine.

It's a narrative retcon masquerading as a plot. That future, the one with death camps and bald Professor X in a wheelchair, is replaced by a brighter one.

We see it in the film’s final moments:

Jean Grey is alive, Cyclops is alive, and the Xavier Institute is thriving. The hellscape future? Gone. That’s the power of a butterfly effect, mutant-style.

But the timeline fix isn’t just fan service.

It’s a way to clean house.

After The Last Stand and X-Men Origins: Wolverine drew heavy criticism, Fox needed a reboot without starting from zero. Days of Future Past gave them that—a soft reset, not a total reboot. They kept the same actors, the same universe, but erased the parts they didn’t want anymore.

The result is two timelines: the “Original” (2000–2013) and the “Revised” (post-1973 changes).

There’s a deeper thematic point, too. The film is obsessed with regret, redemption, and the idea that people—and stories—can change.

Charles Xavier regains hope.

Erik isn’t doomed to always be the villain...

Even Raven, long painted as lost to darkness, becomes the agent of change. Days of Future Past isn't just rewriting history; it’s arguing that the future isn’t fixed. And in doing so, it gives the franchise the chance to evolve.

Of course, later films like Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix don’t always make good on that promise.
30 April 2025

How does the X-Men films' timeline work?

A Guide to the X-Men Film Timelines

The X-Men film universe is notoriously tricky. Twisting timelines, alternate histories, and rewritten destinies have become almost as iconic as the mutant heroes themselves. This complexity stems from the series' willingness to engage with core comic book themes of alternate realities and the consequences of changing the past. The central conflict has always been the philosophical war between Professor Charles Xavier, who believes in peaceful coexistence, and Erik Lehnsherr, Magneto, who believes in mutant supremacy as the only path to survival. Their struggle forms the soul of the franchise.

However, the narrative lynchpin of the entire saga is the 2014 film, X-Men: Days of Future Past. This film establishes a dark potential future where advanced robotic Sentinels have driven mutants to the brink of extinction. To prevent this outcome, Wolverine's consciousness is sent back to his younger body in 1973. His actions there successfully avert the Sentinel apocalypse but also create a massive fracture in the timeline, effectively resetting the canon and creating a new, divergent path. This guide separates the films into these two distinct timelines to provide a clear understanding of the complete, albeit complex, saga.

Time travel changes things.
January Jones / Emma Frost X-Men: First Class (2011)
January Jones as Emma Frost in X-Men: First Class (2011)

The Original Timeline

X-Men: First ClassReleased: 2011

Timeline: 1962

Set during the Cuban Missile Crisis, this film is the foundational story for the entire franchise. It details the powerful bond and eventual ideological split between a young Charles Xavier and Erik Lehnsherr. We witness the formation of the first X-Men team and see how their differing views on humanity—hope versus fear—set them on a collision course that would define mutantkind for decades.

X-Men Origins: WolverineReleased: 2009

Timeline: ~1845-1979

This entry chronicles over a century of Logan's life, from the traumatic discovery of his powers to his violent service in numerous wars alongside his brother, Victor Creed. The main plot focuses on his recruitment into the Weapon X program, where Colonel William Stryker bonds adamantium to his skeleton, and the tragedy that leads to his profound memory loss, setting up the character we meet in later films.

X-MenReleased: 2000

Timeline: 2000

The film that launched the modern superhero genre. An amnesiac Logan and a young runaway, Rogue, are drawn into the central conflict between the X-Men and Magneto's Brotherhood. Magneto’s plan to use a machine to forcibly mutate world leaders at a UN summit on Ellis Island showcases his extremist methods, while the X-Men's grounded, black-leather aesthetic established a new, more serious tone for comic book adaptations.

X2: X-Men UnitedReleased: 2003

Timeline: 2003

Colonel Stryker returns, leading a military assault on Xavier’s mansion and executing a plan to build his own Cerebro to eradicate all mutants. This forces an uneasy but necessary alliance between the X-Men and the Brotherhood. The film culminates in Jean Grey's apparent sacrifice at Alkali Lake, where she unleashes a glimpse of her immense Phoenix powers to save her friends.

X-Men: The Last StandReleased: 2006

Timeline: 2006

A "cure" for the mutant gene creates a deep societal divide. This conflict is tragically overshadowed by the return of Jean Grey, now resurrected as the uncontrollably powerful Dark Phoenix. Her immense destructive power leads to the deaths of key characters, including Cyclops and Professor Xavier, making this one of the darkest chapters in the original timeline.

The WolverineReleased: 2013

Timeline: 2013

Haunted by the death of Jean Grey, Logan lives in self-imposed exile. He is summoned to Japan by an old acquaintance who offers him a chance to shed his immortality. The story is a more personal exploration of Logan’s curse of eternal life and his struggle to find meaning beyond being a weapon, before a post-credits scene brings him back into the central mutant conflict.

X-Men: Days of Future PastReleased: 2014

Timeline: 2023

The grim conclusion of this timeline. In a desolate future, nearly all mutants and their human allies have been exterminated by hyper-advanced Sentinels. As a last resort, Kitty Pryde sends Wolverine’s consciousness back in time to prevent the key historical event that led to the Sentinels' creation, setting the stage for the timeline to be rewritten.

The Altered Timeline

X-Men: Days of Future PastReleased: 2014

Timeline: 1973

The 1973 section of the film is the lynchpin of the entire franchise. By preventing Mystique from assassinating Bolivar Trask and being captured, the team successfully averts the dark future. This act creates a new divergent path, erasing the specific events of the original trilogy and allowing for a new history to be written from this point forward.

X-Men: ApocalypseReleased: 2016

Timeline: 1983

A decade into the new timeline, the world’s first and most powerful mutant, En Sabah Nur, awakens. Believing humanity needs to be cleansed, he recruits four powerful "horsemen," including a disillusioned Magneto. This global threat forces Professor X to assemble a new, younger team of X-Men, including the formative versions of Cyclops, Jean Grey, and Storm.

X-Men: Dark PhoenixReleased: 2019

Timeline: 1992

In this revised history, the X-Men are national heroes. During a rescue mission in space, Jean Grey absorbs a cosmic solar flare that unlocks the Phoenix Force within her. This version of the classic story focuses less on a dual personality and more on Jean’s struggle to control a power that amplifies her trauma and threatens to consume everything she loves, fracturing the X-Men from within.

Deadpool & Deadpool 2Released: 2016 & 2018

Timeline: Modern Day

These satirical films exist loosely within the altered timeline, a fact they frequently and humorously acknowledge. Wade Wilson's fourth-wall-breaking commentary often includes jokes about the convoluted continuity, making these films both a part of the universe and a commentary on it.

LoganReleased: 2017

Timeline: 2029

Presented as a potential, definitive end for this timeline's Wolverine. In a bleak future where new mutants are no longer born, a world-weary Logan cares for an elderly Charles Xavier, whose powerful mind is deteriorating. Their story concludes with a final, brutal mission to protect a young mutant clone of Wolverine, serving as a poignant and tragic finale for the iconic characters.

Chronological order of the 'Alien' film movies + 'in universe' time line watch list

A Chronological Guide to the Alien Film Universe

The Alien franchise kicked off in 1979 with Ridley Scott’s landmark film, Alien, quickly setting a new standard for science fiction horror. But as the series expanded - moving both forward and backward through its own timeline - the chronology became just as intriguing as the movies themselves. 

This guide is your map to navigating the Alien series in two key ways: the order of release and the in-universe timeline.

 Because the films weren’t released sequentially, experiencing them by either method tells a very different story.

From Scott’s dark vision of space terror to James Cameron’s action-packed sequel Aliens, each film reshapes the Alien mythos.

Later entries like David Fincher’s bleak Alien 3 and Jean-Pierre Jeunet’s far-future Alien: Resurrection take the saga into grim new territory. But the franchise didn’t just move forward; it also traveled back. Prequels Prometheus and Alien: Covenant jumped centuries earlier to explore humanity’s disastrous first contacts with the origins of the terrifying Xenomorph. 

In space no one can hear you scream.

The Prequel Era

PrometheusReleased: 2012

Timeline: 2089–2093

A team of scientists, funded by the dying billionaire Peter Weyland, travels to the distant moon LV-223 seeking humanity's creators, the "Engineers." Instead of benevolent gods, they find a derelict bioweapons facility. This film explores the theme of flawed creation on multiple levels: the Engineers created humanity, humanity created the synthetic David, and both creations ultimately rebel. The crew's quest for answers unleashes the Engineers' black pathogen, a mutagenic agent that results in horrific lifeforms and signals the birth of a cosmic nightmare.

Lore Note: The film was initially developed as a direct prequel to Alien, but Ridley Scott pivoted to make it a more standalone story that explores the larger universe, though it clearly sets up the events of the original film.

Alien: CovenantReleased: 2017

Timeline: 2104

A decade later, the colony ship Covenant diverts to an uncharted paradise world. There they find David, the android survivor of the Prometheus mission, who has taken on the role of a mad biologist. In a dark twist on Frankenstein, David reveals he used the black pathogen to eradicate the Engineers and has spent the last ten years methodically experimenting to engineer the perfect organism. This film serves as a grim bridge, explicitly showing how David’s nihilistic obsession with creation leads directly to the iconic Xenomorph.

Lore Note: This film introduces the "Neomorph," a pale, more organic precursor to the Xenomorph. Its disturbingly rapid and violent life cycle was conceived to show an earlier, more chaotic stage of David's experiments before he perfected his "symphony of death."

The Pre-Ripley Era

Alien: Earth (TV Series)Expected: 2025

Timeline: 2120

Marking the franchise’s first major story set on Earth, this prequel series unfolds just two years before the events of the original film. A crashed alien spacecraft triggers a high-stakes investigation by a tactical team led by Wendy, the first hybrid synth infused with human consciousness. The show promises to explore themes of corporate espionage between Weyland-Yutani and its rivals, as well as the terrifying implications of a Xenomorph outbreak on our home world.

Lore Note: Helmed by Noah Hawley (Fargo, Legion), the series is expected to focus more on the human drama and class conflict sparked by the alien threat, rather than being a pure creature feature, offering a new perspective on the universe.

The Ripley Saga

AlienReleased: 1979

Timeline: 2122

Famously pitched as "Jaws in space," this film establishes the "truckers in space" aesthetic, focusing on the blue-collar crew of the towing vessel Nostromo. After investigating a distress signal on the moon LV-426, they unwittingly bring a deadly stowaway aboard. The film is a masterclass in claustrophobic horror, but its central theme is corporate indifference. The reveal of Special Order 937 - "Crew expendable" - shows that the true monster is not just the alien, but the company that sent them to die for a profit.

Lore Note: The "Space Jockey," the giant fossilized alien pilot discovered by the Nostromo crew, was a central mystery for decades until its species was identified as an "Engineer" in Prometheus.

Alien: RomulusReleased: 2024

Timeline: ~2142 (Between Alien and Aliens)

Set between the first two films, this story follows a group of young space colonizers scavenging a derelict Weyland-Yutani research station, the "Romulus." In their search for salvageable tech, they unleash the same terror that plagued the Nostromo. The film is a deliberate return to the franchise's horror roots, focusing on a new generation's terrifying first encounter with the Xenomorph in a tense, claustrophobic setting.

Lore Note: Director Fede Álvarez made a conscious effort to use practical effects, miniatures, and puppetry wherever possible to recapture the tangible, gritty aesthetic of the original 1979 film.

AliensReleased: 1986

Timeline: 2179

Rescued after 57 years in hypersleep, Ripley reluctantly returns to LV-426 as an advisor to a squad of overconfident Colonial Marines. Director James Cameron masterfully shifts the genre from horror to high-octane action, exploring themes of militarism and motherhood. The film's emotional core is the bond between the traumatized Ripley and the orphaned girl Newt, which culminates in a primal battle between two mothers—Ripley in her Power Loader and the colossal Alien Queen protecting her eggs.

Lore Note: The iconic M41A Pulse Rifle props were built using parts from a WWII-era M1A1 Thompson submachine gun and a Franchi SPAS-12 shotgun, giving them a realistic, functional weight and feel.

Alien 3Released: 1992

Timeline: 2179

This installment is a return to bleak, nihilistic horror. Ripley's escape pod crashes on Fiorina "Fury" 161, a desolate foundry and penal colony. Stripped of weapons and hope, Ripley must rally the cynical inmates to fight a new, faster Xenomorph. The film explores themes of faith and futility, culminating in the horrifying discovery that Ripley is carrying a Queen embryo, forcing her into an ultimate act of self-sacrifice to end the species.

Lore Note: The film's famously troubled production meant it began shooting without a finished script. A later "Assembly Cut" restored over 30 minutes of footage, creating a more coherent (and fan-preferred) version that better explores the religious and existential themes.

Alien: ResurrectionReleased: 1997

Timeline: 2379

Two hundred years after her death, military scientists clone Ripley to resurrect the Queen embryo inside her. The result, "Ripley 8," is a human-Xenomorph hybrid with terrifying new abilities. She teams with a crew of space pirates to escape the research station after the cloned aliens inevitably escape. The film has a unique tone of grotesque black comedy and explores themes of genetic corruption and corporate science run amok, culminating in a bizarre and tragic confrontation with the "Newborn" hybrid.

Lore Note: The screenplay was written by Joss Whedon, who would later direct The Avengers. He has since expressed his dissatisfaction with the final film, stating that the execution did not match his original vision for the script.

The Crossover Films

Alien vs. PredatorReleased: 2004

Timeline: 2004

Set in the present day, this film posits that Predators have been visiting Earth for centuries, using humans as hosts to breed Xenomorphs as part of a ritualistic hunt. A Weyland Corporation team discovers an ancient pyramid under the Antarctic ice and becomes trapped between the two warring species. The film serves as a fun "what if" scenario, merging two iconic sci-fi horror mythologies.

Lore Note: While a fun concept, this film and its sequel are not considered part of the official canon of the main "Alien" saga, as their timeline and lore (particularly that humanity knew of Xenomorphs in 2004) directly contradict the events of "Prometheus" and "Alien."

Aliens vs. Predator: RequiemReleased: 2007

Timeline: 2004

Picking up immediately after the first AVP, a Predator ship carrying a "Predalien" (a Xenomorph that gestated in a Predator) crashes near a small town in Colorado. A lone, veteran Predator is dispatched to hunt the terrifying new hybrid and clean up the resulting Xenomorph infestation before it consumes the entire town. Its tone is significantly darker and more violent than its predecessor.

Lore Note: The film was heavily criticized for its extremely dark lighting, which made many of the action sequences difficult to see. The directors defended this as an artistic choice to enhance the horror and chaos.

Review Analysis of Andor Season 2, Episode 6 - "What a festive evening"

Star Wars is full of flashy battles, mythic heroes, and grand cosmic dramas.

But Andor cuts differently. It’s about the dirty, painful grind of rebellionthe sacrifices, the compromises, the small victories stained with blood

Episode 6, "What a Festive Evening," is a prime example of how this series gets it right: deep, smart, ruthless. It’s not about heroes swinging lightsabers; it's about regular people trapped in history’s crossfire, their choices adding up to something big.

This episode weaves between two threads, Ghorman and Coruscant, both dripping with tension. 

On Ghorman, rebellion isn’t just brewing - it’s boiling over. Cassian Andor senses disaster from the start, seeing clearly what the local rebels can’t: their unpreparedness, their vulnerability. It’s a pattern he’s learned the hard way, through bruises and losses and near misses. And yet, even he can't prevent the chaos. 

A daring heist against the Empire succeeds at first but quickly spirals into tragedy when Samm, a rookie rebel, accidentally kills Cinta Kaz, shattering Vel Sartha’s world.

Cinta’s death isn't just shock value. It feels brutally real, messy, avoidable - the way real-life tragedies often do. Vel’s grief lands hard. She might radicalize futher, or she might crumble. 

Either way, her loss pushes the stakes higher, underlining Luthen Rael’s chilling calculation: “It will burn very brightly.” Luthen isn't heartless exactly - he's strategic, detached, willing to sacrifice pawns if it ignites the galaxy. It’s cold pragmatism masked as revolution, forcing Cassian to confront how far he's willing to go, how much pain he can bear.

And the Empire isn’t blind. 

Dedra Meero, ever ambitious, lets the rebels run wild on purpose, cultivating chaos to justify harsher crackdowns. Her manipulation of Syril Karn - still hopelessly eager for her approval - cements his role as the Empire’s most pathetic pawn. Dedra's cruel brilliance reminds us how tyranny thrives not just through force but manipulation, exploiting idealism and desperation in equal measure.

Meanwhile, on Coruscant, the glittering heart of the galaxy’s rot, Luthen and Kleya infiltrate a lavish party at Davo Sculdun’s mansion to retrieve a hidden spy device. 
Krennic

It's espionage at its best: smooth, dangerous, nearly unraveling when Director Orson Krennic shows up unexpectedly. Benjamin Bratt’s quick cameo as Bail Organa - standing in for Jimmy Smits - adds subtle tension, his cautious exchange with Mon Mothma hinting at deeper alliances forming quietly in the shadows.

But it’s Bix Caleen’s story that hits hardest. Still haunted by torture at Dr. Gorst’s hands, she tracks him down and serves him a dose of his own brutality. This moment - raw, cathartic, violent - feels like justice, even if fleeting. 

It’s not just revenge. It's reclamation. 

A statement that the Empire's cruelty won't go unanswered, that the scars they leave can be weapons turned against them. Her bond with Cassian anchors this act of defiance, a glimpse into the heart that keeps their rebellion alive.

Saw Gerrera makes a brief but crucial appearance, spiraling further into fanaticism, now training rebels on D’Qar - a planet destined for greater significance down the line. His fixation on rhydonium, a volatile fuel tied to personal tragedy, offers a haunting backstory that deepens his extremism. Saw’s storyline isn't just fan service - it explains the fractures within the rebellion, the rival philosophies vying for dominance: 

Luthen’s calculated strategy versus Saw’s radicalized fury.

Character-wise, the episode moves everyone forward meaningfully. Cassian's evolution from skeptic to reluctant protector deepens. Vel faces unbearable loss. Bix regains agency violently but powerfully. Luthen grows colder, more committed, dangerously close to losing touch with the humanity he's supposedly fighting for. Dedra sharpens her claws, and Syril sinks deeper into his delusions. And Mon Mothma continues her precarious balancing act, subtly marshaling power right under Imperial noses.

Plot-wise, everything escalates sharply. 

The Ghorman heist crystallizes the messy realities of rebellion. The spy device on Coruscant highlights Luthen’s high-risk, high-reward game, and Bix’s revenge injects visceral personal stakes. These threads connect brilliantly, underscoring the central theme: the human cost of resistance, the bitter choices made in dark places.

Thematically, sacrifice looms large—the painful decisions rebels make, knowingly and unknowingly, willingly and unwillingly. Manipulation and deception blur moral lines, questioning if the means justify the ends. And there's trauma, ever-present, haunting characters like Bix, shaping them into fighters who use their pain as fuel.

The episode doesn’t forget its Star Wars roots, either. Clever references pepper the narrative: Senator Organa, Saw’s tragic Onderon past, the rhydonium callbacks. D'Qar, familiar from the sequel trilogy, emerges as a crucial rebel haven. Even podracing makes a cheeky return. These touches reward attentive viewers, grounding Andor firmly within the broader saga while carving its own gritty identity.

Ultimately, "What a Festive Evening" nails exactly why Andor stands apart. 

It’s mature without being dour, intense without losing nuance. It respects its characters, recognizing their complexities, their failures, their humanity. Rebellion isn’t glamorous here—it’s gritty, costly, heartbreaking. Yet it's hopeful too, because amid all the pain, connections endure, resilience grows, and ordinary people become extraordinary, even if only for a moment.

And that's powerful storytelling—Star Wars at its bravest and most insightful, proving again why Andor is quietly redefining the galaxy far, far away.

Why was C3PO’s mind wiped but not R2D2’s?

The enduring saga of Star Wars has captivated audiences for decades, populated by a memorable cast of characters, both organic and artificial. 

Among the most iconic are the droids C3PO and R2D2, a bickering protocol droid and a resourceful astromech, who have been present for nearly every major event in the galaxy far, far away since the Clone Wars. 

Their constant presence makes a particular narrative decision all the more intriguing: the memory wipe of C3PO at the end of the prequel trilogy, specifically in Revenge of the Sith, while R2D2 retained his full memory banks. 

This difference in their treatment is not a minor detail but a deliberate narrative choice that influences our understanding of the characters, the plot, and even the way the story itself is presented.

The instance of C3PO’s memory wipe is explicitly shown at the conclusion of Revenge of the Sith. Following the dramatic rise of the Galactic Empire and the secret birth of Luke and Leia Skywalker, Senator Bail Organa, a key figure in the burgeoning rebellion and Leia's adoptive father, recognizes the critical need to conceal the children's existence from the Emperor and the newly christened Darth Vader. 

Why was C3PO’s mind wiped but not R2D2’s?


In a pivotal scene, Organa instructs Captain Raymus Antilles of the Tantive IV to ensure the protocol droid's memory is erased. The in-universe justification for this drastic action is clear: to protect the Skywalker twins by preventing C3PO, with his vast knowledge of galactic affairs and protocols, from inadvertently revealing their identities or location.

The novelization of Revenge of the Sith provides further context for Organa's decision. In this expanded version, after Padmé Amidala’s passing, the droids are entrusted to Captain Antilles with the understanding that they will eventually serve Leia. Upon hearing this, C3PO excitedly declares his intention to tell Leia all about her parents, Master Anakin and Senator Amidala. This near-disclosure underscores C3PO’s fundamental inability to keep sensitive information private, solidifying the necessity of the memory wipe in Organa’s estimation.

Conversely, R2D2’s memory is never fully erased within the core Star Wars saga. 

This divergence in the treatment of the two droids is significant. While an incident in The Clone Wars animated series depicts both droids having their memories temporarily wiped by the bounty hunter Cad Bane, this event occurs years before Revenge of the Sith and does not impact R2D2’s knowledge of the Skywalker family's secrets. 

A popular fan interpretation, supported by subtle hints within the films, suggests that Anakin Skywalker himself was against wiping R2D2’s memory, valuing the astromech’s accumulated experiences and resourcefulness. Furthermore, the canonical anthology Return of the Jedi: From a Certain Point of View reveals that R2D2 acknowledges undergoing only minor, selective memory erasures specifically to protect his companions, reinforcing that his core memories remain intact.

The memory wipe of C3PO also serves a crucial narrative function in bridging the gap between the prequel and original trilogies. 

Without this plot point, a significant continuity issue would arise: 

C3PO’s extensive interactions with Obi-Wan Kenobi during the prequel trilogy would logically lead to recognition in A New Hope. The memory wipe thus provides a plausible in-universe explanation for C3PO’s apparent lack of recognition of the old Jedi Master. 

Some accounts suggest George Lucas had considered this memory wipe from the early stages of developing the original trilogy as a way of maintaining narrative coherence.

Beyond immediate plot mechanics, the roles of C3PO and R2D2 can be viewed through the lens of narration within the Star Wars films. 

George Lucas himself has described R2D2 as the ultimate narrator of the entire Skywalker saga. According to this concept, the events we witness are essentially R2D2 recounting them to the Keeper of the Journal of the Whills, a century after the conclusion of Return of the Jedi. This framing emphasizes the importance of R2D2’s intact memory. Conversely, C3PO, with his memory loss and tendency toward exaggeration and anxiety, can be seen as a less reliable narrator. 

Their contrasting viewpoints and levels of knowledge enrich the storytelling, offering both comedic relief and distinct perspectives on unfolding events. The droids can even be interpreted as a "Greek Chorus," providing commentary that guides the audience’s understanding.

The decision to wipe only C3PO’s memory appears to stem directly from his fundamental personality trait: his talkative nature and his inability to keep secrets, making him a significant security risk in a galaxy filled with conflict and sensitive information. His near-revelation of Leia’s parentage in the Revenge of the Sith novelization and his immediate disclosure of Leia’s rebel affiliation in A New Hope illustrate this tendency vividly. 

In stark contrast, R2D2 has consistently demonstrated discretion, understanding the importance of secrecy. Despite possessing a wealth of sensitive information, he reliably keeps it confidential, acting strategically when necessary. Additionally, the very nature of R2D2’s binary communication provides an inherent layer of security.

About the author Jimmy Jangles


My name is Jimmy Jangles, the founder of The Astromech. I have always been fascinated by the world of science fiction, especially the Star Wars universe, and I created this website to share my love for it with fellow fans.

At The Astromech, you can expect to find a variety of articles, reviews, and analysis related to science fiction, including books, movies, TV, and games.
From exploring the latest news and theories to discussing the classics, I aim to provide entertaining and informative content for all fans of the genre.

Whether you are a die-hard Star Trek fan or simply curious about the world of science fiction, The Astromech has something for everyone. So, sit back, relax, and join me on this journey through the stars!
Back to Top