The Comedian's Badge as a metaphor for all that is wrong in the world of Watchmen

07 April 2023
The yellow button in Alan Moore's graphic novel "Watchmen" is a powerful thematic device that serves multiple purposes throughout the story. At its most basic level, the button is a simple physical object that was once worn by The Comedian, one of the masked vigilantes who once patrolled the streets of New York City in the 1960s and 70s. However, as the story progresses, the button takes on a deeper meaning and becomes a symbol of many of the book's core themes.

One of the most important themes of "Watchmen" is the idea of legacy and the ways in which the past influences the present. The yellow button is a physical link between the present-day world of the story and the past of the masked vigilantes. 

It is a tangible reminder of the fact that the characters' actions in the past continue to reverberate through time, influencing the events of the present day. The button also represents the idea that the past can never truly be left behind, no matter how hard we try to move on from it.

Another key theme of "Watchmen" is the question of power and who has the right to wield it. The yellow button serves as a powerful symbol of this theme, as it is a physical representation of the power that the masked vigilantes once held over the city.

comedian yellow badge symbolism watchmen
  
The Comedian's legacy is a significant aspect of the story of Watchmen, and the smiley face button serves as a reminder of the character's violent actions and their impact on the world. The Comedian is a complicated character who embodies the darker side of heroism. He is willing to commit terrible acts in the name of what he believes is right (and even for his own cruel amusement) , and his actions have far-reaching consequences. The smiley face button on his uniform is a symbol of his legacy, which is one of violence and brutality.

The blood stain on the Comedian's badge is a powerful visual symbol that holds multiple interpretations and layers of meaning. One of the most prominent interpretations of the blood stain is that it resembles an arrow pointing from the center of the round smiley face into the upper left quadrant, which is often associated with the position of the minute hand on a clock pointing at 12 minutes to the hour. This interpretation is significant as it ties in with the overarching theme of the book, which is the looming threat of catastrophic destruction and the countdown to the end of the world, represented by the Doomsday Clock.

The idea of the blood stain representing the minute hand of a clock pointing at 12 minutes to the hour highlights the sense of urgency and inevitability that runs throughout the story. It suggests that time is running out, and that the world is perilously close to destruction. This interpretation is also supported by the fact that the Doomsday Clock is a recurring motif in the book, representing how close the world is to global catastrophe.

However, the blood stain can also be interpreted as a symbol of the flaw or taint that lies beneath the surface of things. The Comedian's badge is a symbol of law and order, but the blood stain suggests that this order is built on a foundation of violence and falsehood. This interpretation ties in with the book's broader themes of corruption, disillusionment, and the fragility of the social order. The blood stain serves as a reminder that things are not always as they seem, and that even the most seemingly stable structures can be built on shaky foundations.

The fragility of human life is another theme that the smiley face button represents. The button is shown juxtaposed with the bloodstains from the Comedian's murder, emphasizing the brutal and sudden nature of death. The button serves as a reminder that anyone can be a victim of violence or tragedy at any time. The fragility of human life is a recurring theme in the story, and the button serves as a visual representation of this theme.

The decay of society is a prevalent theme throughout Watchmen, and the smiley face button represents this decay. As the story progresses, the button becomes more and more worn and dirty, symbolizing the decay of society. The world in which the story takes place is one in which morality and humanity have been lost, and the smiley face button serves as a symbol of this decay.

Dr. Manhattan's detachment from humanity is another theme that the smiley face button represents. Dr. Manhattan wears a symbol similar to the smiley face button on his forehead, which symbolizes his detachment from humanity. Dr. Manhattan is a character who has evolved beyond humanity and has become a god-like figure. The button serves as a reminder of his past as a human and how he has transcended it.

The ultimate futility of heroism is a central theme in Watchmen, and the smiley face button serves as a symbol of this theme. The heroes in the story are unable to prevent the destruction of the world, and the smiley face button becomes a symbol of their failure to make a meaningful impact on the world around them. The button serves as a reminder that heroism is not always effective, and that sometimes, even the most heroic efforts can be futile.

yellow face symbol watchmen

The Comedian's Badge 'face' is used as a recurring motif throughout the entire graphic novel

The badge is a recurring motif in the graphic novel, Watchmen, and is used to represent different themes and ideas throughout the story. 

The use of the badge is first seen in Chapter I, page 5 when Rorschach fires his grappling gun, and the hook and resulting smoke trail resemble the pattern of the blood splatter. 

This sets the tone for the use of the badge as a symbol of violence and death. In Chapter II, page 7, when Hooded Justice prevents Blake from raping Sally Jupiter, Blake bleeds on his yellow jumpsuit in the same position he wears the badge at the time of his death, further reinforcing the idea of the badge being associated with death.

In Chapter II, page 14, when Blake is slashed across the face by the pregnant Vietnamese woman, some of his blood falls on the smiley badge, mimicking the familiar pattern. This highlights the idea that violence and death are recurring themes in the story. In Chapter II, page 17, the pattern of the liquid splatter on the Owlship resembles the smiley badge, showing how the badge has become a symbol of violence and destruction.

In Chapter III, page 18, a plug socket on a curbside recharge point for electric cars slightly resembles a yellow face with black eyes. There is a shadow at the top left, in the approximate position of the blood on the Comedian's badge, further emphasizing the recurring motif of violence.

In Chapter IV, page 19, on the close-up of the Comedian on the final panel, a drop of his sweat falls onto the same place of the badge as the blood droplet does, further connecting the badge to the Comedian's violent death.

In Chapter V, pages 7 and 22, a religious poster featuring Buddha with a yellow sun behind his head is spattered with a spot of blood. The blood marks the sun in the same position as the blood on the badge, and also covers the Buddha's left eye, suggesting that violence is present even in religious contexts.

In Chapter V, page 15, when Ozymandias is beating his would-be assassin, some blood flies in front of the yellow flower on his lapel, making it resemble the smile button. The position of the flower on Ozymadias' lapel is the same as the position of the badge on Blake's lapel at the time of his death.

In Chapter V, pages 20-21, the yellow shark that is stabbed in one eye by the protagonist of Marooned comes to resemble the smiley badge, further emphasizing the motif of violence and death.

In Chapter VI, page 25, the shape of the dogs' blood on Rorschach's chest resembles that of the blood splatter on the badge, showing how violence and death have become a part of Rorschach's identity.

In Chapter VII, the Nite Owl goggles, which are covered with dust except for a patch she wiped off which mimics the blood spatter, reflect the front of the Owlship, which mimics the smiley face. Dreiberg pictures the Comedian's bloody badge when he remembers Rorschach's warnings about a "mask killer," further emphasizing the motif of violence.

In Chapter VII, page 13, Dreiberg is cleaning the steam off of his right lens of his glasses. In the left lens, you can see a smiley face with the left eye darker, representing the blood splatter. In Chapter VII, page 18, when Dreiberg looks at the moon out of his window, two water droplets in the position of a pair of eyes and a cloud in the position of a mouth make it resemble a smiley face, connecting the motif of violence to the larger context of the story.

In Chapter XI, page 16: The smiley face can be seen on the surface of Jupiter after Dr. Manhattan's disappearance, with the Great Red Spot forming the smile and the Southern Equatorial Belt forming the eyes. The face also appears on the top of a salt shaker on the same page, with the salt grains forming the smile and the shaker's lid forming the eyes.

Chapter XI, page 25: Veidt's assistant, Lynx, wears a t-shirt with a smiley face on it. The smiley face has a bullet hole through the forehead, resembling the Comedian's badge. Chapter XI, page 28: On the last page of the graphic novel, a New Frontiersman employee finds Rorschach's journal and a drop of his blood falls onto the front cover, forming a smiley face.

The use of the badge as a recurring motif in Watchmen serves to tie together the different characters, events, and themes in the story. The blood splatter pattern on the badge is particularly significant, as it represents the violent and chaotic nature of the world in which the story takes place. The badge is also a symbol of the superhero genre, which is deconstructed and criticized throughout the graphic novel.

The badge is first seen in Chapter I, page 5, when Rorschach fires his grappling gun and the resulting smoke trail resembles the blood splatter pattern on the badge. This sets the tone for the rest of the story, as it establishes a link between Rorschach's violent actions and the violent world of Watchmen.

In Chapter II, page 7, Hooded Justice prevents the Comedian from raping Sally Jupiter, and the Comedian bleeds on his yellow jumpsuit in the same position he wears the badge at the time of his death. This foreshadows the Comedian's eventual death and links it to the badge.

Chapter II, page 14, shows the Comedian being slashed across the face by the pregnant Vietnamese woman, and some of his blood falls on the smiley badge, mimicking the familiar pattern. This reinforces the link between the badge and violence, and also suggests that the Comedian's violent past has caught up with him.

In conclusion, the smiley face button is a powerful symbol that represents various themes throughout the story of Watchmen. It serves as a reminder of the Comedian's legacy, the fragility of human life, the decay of society, Dr. Manhattan's detachment from humanity, and the ultimate futility of heroism. The button is a central and powerful image that ties together many of the story's themes and ideas.

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Powered by Blogger.

About the author Jimmy Jangles


My name is Jimmy Jangles, the founder of The Astromech. I have always been fascinated by the world of science fiction, especially the Star Wars universe, and I created this website to share my love for it with fellow fans.

At The Astromech, you can expect to find a variety of articles, reviews, and analysis related to science fiction, including books, movies, TV, and games.
From exploring the latest news and theories to discussing the classics, I aim to provide entertaining and informative content for all fans of the genre.

Whether you are a die-hard Star Trek fan or simply curious about the world of science fiction, The Astromech has something for everyone. So, sit back, relax, and join me on this journey through the stars!
Back to Top